Reading Log
These are NOT spoiler-free!
Not full reviews really - just a place to jot down my thoughts :)
Rating: ★★★✫✰ (3.5 stars)
This was an interesting read. I enjoyed how it explored multiple generations of characters and relationships in a relatively short amount of pages. The characters were distinct and their juxtaposition with each other had a lot to say about cycles of abuse, healthy vs. unhealthy relationships, and doing what you have to do to survive.
Unfortunately it was difficult to finish - not boring, just sometimes hard to understand and follow. What happens to T-Mo/Odysseus at the end also undermines what I thought the theme was building up. It seemed Odysseus was the "abusive side" of T-Mo in a literal symbol of the way abusers seem to have "sides" to them; victims cannot keep T-Mo (the funny and loving husband) without having Odysseus (the violent predator). However, in the end, the women that love him just... remove Odysseus and keep T-Mo, insinuating that this sexual and physical abuser was just a good person with a bad person inside of him.
Still, I would recommend this book if you want to explore intergenerational trauma in a novel-length fantastical setting. I think there might be more engaging reads out there on the subject, but this still has interesting things to say.
Rating: ★★★✫✰ (3.5 stars)
I've seen a lot of reviews about how this is unlike any book they've read before, and I for sure agree.
It was genuinely hard for me to finish, due to its behemoth size and the circularity + relative directionlessness of the plot. However, parts that went nowhere and were never expanded upon were bookends to beautiful prose and extremely poignant ideas. The ever-present metaphor of the endless hungry road really emerged as the book continued. It depicts an African country in political upheaval, caught between worlds and dragged towards capitalism and industrialization, and likens it to a struggling cycle of death and rebirth as experienced by the spirit-child Azuro.
Would I read it again? No - I'll pass it along. Sometimes my attempts to push through would give me a headache, and I had to force myself to finish, so unfortunately while the circular narrative and hefty descriptions of spirits served to develop the book's message and metaphors, for me there was just so much listless wandering around that it knocks the score down. But I'm very glad to have come across it and read it.
Rating: ★★★★✫ (4.5 stars)
This was so original and gripping! I became so invested in the relationship between Binti and Okwu. The book's main question is that of identity, and this is explored through multiple avenues: who are you when you're away from home for the first time? Who are you when your life plans completely change? Who are you when your very DNA changes and your body becomes unfamiliar?
Some plot elements felt a bit underdeveloped or confusing, but to me the rest of the trilogy was worth some weaker points. I highly recommend!
Rating: ★★★★✰ (4 stars)
I really liked this space fantasy! It was short and compelling, but managed to create the impression of a wider world that you're just getting a glimpse of. It starts in the aftermath of a wider issue and I enjoyed reading a story where massive conflict is just behind, not just ahead. I enjoyed seeing the main character learn to open up after a long time alone post-conflict. I couldn't really care for the romance between her and her love-interest, but romances are very hard to convince me of, so I don't knock the book for that and thought they had some nice moments.
Ultimately, 4 stars just because I wasn't totally blown away I suppose, but it's a subtler book with some interesting woven worldbuilding, and it made me interested in the author's other works!
Rating: ★★★★✰ (4 stars)
Really good near-future speculation on a species that evolves language so very unlike our own!
There's an impressive amount tackled in this book, from automation-for-profit to artificially-intelligent "people" to capitalistic greed and to forced labor in fisheries. While the most exciting things were the entirely fictional elements, like the futuristic tech and the language that octopi would develop, this book laid down explorations of a myriad of current real-world issues. I picked this book up for the linguistic fiction and stayed for the commentary about nature, capitalism, and consciousness.
I do feel like some ideas were underdeveloped, but writing this review now, the actual issues I had with this book escape me, so it left quite the positive impression.